LiDAR vs InSAR

Monday, 23 August 2021

LiDAR vs. InSAR


Two ground-breaking technologies. Two rich histories. LiDAR vs. InSAR – how do they stack up? What do we say when customers ask us about LiDAR?

Powerful Processes


Shortly after the development of the laser, the first light detection and ranging (LiDAR) system was introduced in 1961. Intended for satellite tracking for NASA, the system combined laser-focused imaging with the ability to calculate distances by measuring the time for a signal to return using appropriate sensors and data acquisition electronics.

Since then, LiDAR has been powerfully advanced to become a system of data collection that uses laser pulses to illuminate the target and reflect back to the sensors. This reflected light is analysed using the time-of-flight calculation to determine the distance to the object, enabling the capturing of large, incredibly accurate quantities of data and three-dimensional information about the Earth’s shape and surface characteristics.

Historical Data Ranges


Interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) was explored in the ‘80s but only came into practical use in the ‘90s. InSAR techniques allow for ongoing movement monitoring as well as the analysis of movements over the last three decades, providing access to historical data-changes to land surface altitude.

Working through the utilisation of a Synthetic Aperture Radar to illuminate a target area, the differences in the waves returning to the satellite determine the imagery. These representations can then be used to generate maps of surface deformation or digital elevation, scaled from single pixels (1m x 1m or 4m x 14m) to entire countries, offering a wide scope of usage.

Head-to-Head


When we compare LiDAR with InSAR, it’s important to remember they have not been designed in parallel competition with one another. They are two differing technologies and as such, have very different advantages and disadvantages. Usefully, both techniques can be employed during day and night, but only InSAR is effective in all weather conditions. Rain, especially, is problematic to LiDAR sensors – droplets can reflect and absorb some of the emitted light beam, degrading their performance.

However, LiDAR produces ultra-high resolution, precise imagery thanks to technology that provides x, y and z coordinates – the production of 3D representations of elevations is easy, helping engineers to quickly draw necessary conclusions.

One direct comparison between the two technologies took place in the early 2000s – the study was based on the digital elevation models (DEM) produced by LiDAR and InSAR and found disparities between their measurements of a specific terrain curvature. It was suggested that the InSAR system had lower spatial resolution, or processing that introduces a bias to lower-curvature surfaces. This project concluded that the LiDAR DEM is more accurate than the InSAR DEM, with less bias and less variance.

Gaining Momentum


It is argued, however, that no other technology can produce as fully-comprehensive surveys as InSAR. It is able to measure surface changes almost as subtle as those detected by individual GPS stations (of less than 1 millimetre) across terrain thousands of kilometres wide. This is reflected in its main uses: measuring displacements on the Earth’s surface and studying deformation caused by subsidence.

InSAR makes our lives safer and offers innovative ways to increase process and practice efficiency. The technology is gaining momentum within large industrial sectors; their reliance on its ability to improve both product and service growing fast.

Revitalising Sectors


Significantly, LiDAR systems come in two distinct types that further enhance precision and industry-specificity – airborne (topographic and bathymetric) and terrestrial (mobile and static).

Topographic LiDAR typically uses a near-infrared laser to map the land, deriving surface models for applications including forestry, geomorphology and urban planning. Bathymetric LiDAR uses water-penetrating green light to measure seafloor and riverbed elevations, capturing geospatial data of coastlines and waters to create hydrographic data.

Mobile LiDAR systems use several lasers that scan multiple angles at the same time, often used for 3D mapping, whereas static LiDAR scans an entire surrounding area or focuses specifically on one region, a popular tool for engineering, architecture and archaeology.

LiDAR DEMs and terrain models play an increasingly crucial role in the planning and construction of roads, large buildings and bridges. It’s also helping to revitalise the automobile sector completely in the form of autonomous vehicles (though not if you ask Elon Musk).

A Match Made in Heaven


While LiDAR establishes itself as a front-runner in the automotive and augmented reality sectors, InSAR data is flooding in – and fast. The amount of civil and commercial SAR satellites in orbit has more than doubled – exciting advancements in computing that eases data processing means that we may soon be able to continually utilise all the data from satellite fleets imaging the entire Earth’s surface. This year, at least a dozen more are set to launch, bringing the total in orbit to a cool figure, over 60.

LiDAR and InSAR are two bespoke advancements that need not be pitched against each other – they’re better together working in cohesion. Integrating these technologies side by side provides an incredibly comprehensive range of monitoring needs that is increasingly accurate and wide-reaching. Focussing on furthering research and innovation for both LiDAR and InSAR, we have the potential to revolutionise decision-making across multiple industries.
SatSense Santa Tracker: Bringing Christmas Magic to Your DoorstepThursday, 05 December 2024 SatSense and Zonguldak Bülent Ecevit University Partner to Revolutionise Ground Movement Monitoring in TürkiyeTuesday, 23 July 2024 SatSense continues to support STEM students to drive innovationWednesday, 08 May 2024 Are UK water companies prepared for another record-breaking summer?Friday, 23 February 2024 Monitoring Rail Infrastructure Using InSARWednesday, 07 February 2024 Revolutionising Infrastructure Monitoring Using InSAR DataThursday, 01 February 2024 SatSense Gets Contract for the DRIPIN Demonstration ProjectWednesday, 24 January 2024 How can asset managers get the most out of InSAR? Monday, 21 August 2023 How can InSAR data be used in GIS software? Monday, 21 August 2023 7 Reasons Why Civil Engineers Should Be Using InSARMonday, 21 August 2023 SatSense and GNS Science Partner to Revolutionise Ground Movement Monitoring in New ZealandThursday, 20 July 2023 Do Onshore Wind Farms Come with Geotechnical Risk?Thursday, 22 September 2022 Our Water Networks Handled the Heat Last Time But What About the Next?Thursday, 11 August 2022 Analysing Bridge Movement Using Satellite DataFriday, 06 May 2022 To What Extent Can We Monitor Ageing Infrastructure?Tuesday, 03 May 2022 The Climate Change Challenge Facing Rail InfrastructureWednesday, 27 April 2022 Keeping Rail Asset Management on the Right Tracks with InSARWednesday, 06 April 2022 Remotely Monitoring Ground Movement for Water UtilitiesTuesday, 22 March 2022 A Damming DilemmaThursday, 10 March 2022 How Can Asset Managers Remotely Monitor Ground Movement?Tuesday, 08 March 2022 Using InSAR to Monitor Assets in Remote LocationsMonday, 28 February 2022 Overcoming Site Monitoring Challenges with InSARWednesday, 23 February 2022 Project Update: Using InSAR Data to Monitor Disused Coal Tips in WalesFriday, 28 January 2022 How Can Remote Technology Aid Tunnelling Engineers?Thursday, 13 January 2022 What Did 2021 Look Like for SatSense?Monday, 20 December 2021 Using InSAR to Monitor Rates of Coastal ErosionWednesday, 15 December 2021 Is it Time to Ground the Extraction of Groundwater?Tuesday, 30 November 2021 SatSense Appoints John McArthur as Chairman to Prepare for Further GrowthTuesday, 30 November 2021 Dam Important DataTuesday, 05 October 2021 Real Time Data Dashboards and the Future of Smart Asset MonitoringTuesday, 05 October 2021 LiDAR vs InSARMonday, 23 August 2021 SatShop Delivers Ground Movement Data at the Click of a ButtonThursday, 29 July 2021 The Light at the End of the TunnelWednesday, 21 July 2021 Join SatSense – we’re hiring!Thursday, 15 July 2021 Analysing movements of the UK’s railway with Network RailThursday, 24 June 2021 Using satellite data to reduce water leakageMonday, 19 April 2021 SatShop portal FAQ’s Friday, 09 April 2021 Satellite data at your fingertipsThursday, 04 March 2021 Avoiding mining disasters with InSAR dataTuesday, 26 January 2021 Using SatSense data to accelerate your geotechnical desk studyWednesday, 16 December 2020 Water treatment works expansionWednesday, 09 December 2020 Using InSAR data to magnify insight in previously unsighted industriesTuesday, 24 November 2020 Ways to improve InSAR data coverageWednesday, 07 October 2020 Automatically detecting movement of infrastructureFriday, 31 July 2020 Getting ground movement direction out of our dataWednesday, 08 July 2020 Creating the SatSense Data PortalTuesday, 07 July 2020 Detecting House Subsidence Using Satellites and InSARFriday, 05 June 2020 Risk indices for detecting ground movement issues using InSARMonday, 01 June 2020 Detecting sinkholes from spaceFriday, 08 May 2020 How SatSense stays ahead of the curveThursday, 07 May 2020 Matt reflects on joining SatSense and says a bit about himselfWednesday, 22 April 2020